Trial and Error

I have been a doctor for 37.5 years and here is one of the major things I have learned: There are many differences in responses to various interventions and treatments that people exhibit. For example, there are some people that categorically will state: This antibiotic (Zithromax for example) never works for me. Despite the fact that specific antibiotics cover specific types of organisms, it should not be the case that a specific antibiotic would fail, but lo and behold, the patient will usually prove his/her admonition.

Let’s turn to the weight control arena. I am often asked by a new patient entering the program: “Am I able to eat____?” That “blank” could be filled in with protein bars, a glass of wine a night, oatmeal in the morning because eggs are despised and lots of other goods/drinks. My answer to people is that the “usual” situation calls for people following our dietary plan to achieve maximal results. Variations off the plan will result in the slowing of the weight loss.

However, everyone is different, meaning that some people can drink alcohol nightly and still lose weight. Others may find that 1-2 drinks a week derail their efforts. Some people need to hit the gym 4-5 times a week despite following the dietary plan whereas others solely need to follow the dietary plan and do not require exercise to lose weight.

Similar to any “experiment” when a scientist is trying to evaluate an intervention, it is wise to only change one variable at a time. So, if you want to see whether eating nuts interferes with weight control (for most people nuts are not good for weight control) only change that one variable. By keeping everything the same (dietary plan phase and exercise patterns), if the nut usage is the only “difference” that week, then see what transpires on the scale. The same holds true for anything else you are considering adding/subtracting from your diet/exercise pattern. Only changing one variable at a time will allow you to pinpoint the effects of that one variable.

Because everyone is a bit different, “trial and error” (or “trial and success”) is sometimes needed to see exactly what you “can” and “cannot” eat/drink during your long term weight control efforts.

Watch the vblog on YouTube

Dr. Robert Posner One of the world’s leading medical weight loss researchers, Robert Posner, MD, operates his state-of-the-art weight loss clinic, Serotonin Plus, in the heart of Burke, Virginia, in the suburban Washington area.

You Might Also Enjoy...

The Cabbage Soup Recipe

This home made cabbage soup will compliment your weight loss week. This recipe is low in calories and high in finer. Do not forget to add enough protein during your week to balance your SP dietary plan.

Parmesan Garlic Veggie Fries

These Parmesan garlic veggie fries are a tasty side dish or snack and a healthy change from potatoes. Oven roasted and topped with salty cheese make these a delicious and healthy dish!

Can Combinations Be Broken?

There are a number of “traditional combinations” that need to be broken up during your long-term weight control journey. Divorcing the fries from the burger won’t cost you any legal fees.

Weight Control and Substitutes

Going out to eat should not be stopped because you are on a long term weight control effort. However, be proactive in ensuring that the meals you order are as compatible as possible with high protein/high vegetable-low carb/low fat/low fruit.


Easy One Pot Authentic Hungarian Goulash Recipe is a hearty, earthy, and meaty stew that brings authentic Hungarian flavor in an easy one-pot stew the whole family will love!